The Best Simple Kalamata Olives Substitutes (2024)

The Best Simple Kalamata Olives Substitutes (1)

Looking for an alternative to Kalamata Olives? You’re in the right place! Keep reading for my favourite simple Kalamata Olives substitutes.

What are Kalamata Olives?

Kalamata Olives are the fruit of the olive tree, a hardy shrub originating in the Mediterranean. Raw olives are incredibly bitter so they need to be preserved by either pickling or salting to remove the bitterness and transform them into a briny punchy flavour bomb.

Simple Kalamata Olives Substitutes

1. Feta

This is taking things in a completely different direction but crumbled feta can provide a salty tang and burst of flavour to replace your olives. If I don’t have olives, feta is my first choice.

2. Capers

While olives tend to be stronger and of course more ‘olive-y’, capers will work in most cases where olives are used.

3. Gerkins or Cornichons

Diced cornichons or gerkins or even dill pickles will provide a little burst of punchy flavour that can work well to replace your olives.

4. Caper Berries

If you do happen to have caper berries, they can be diced and used to replace olives.

5. Roast Almonds or Pinenuts

Roast nuts will provide a similar textural and flavour highlight to a dish that is different from olives yet no less delicious.

6. Fresh Herbs

This is taking things in a completely different direction but torn fresh herbs like basil, flat leaf parsley or tarragon will add a different aromatic flavour highlight to replace the pungent brininess of your olives. In a dish like olive tapenade, the herbs will produce a completely different sauce more like a pesto but it will still be delicious..

7. Preserved Lemons

Another left field idea, but diced preserved lemon flesh will add a tangy saltiness to your dish in a similar manner to olives. As preserved lemon tends to be super salty, start with less and add more as needed.

8. Sea Salt Flakes

If you don’t have any of the above, a good sprinkle of sea salt flakes will go some way to making up the salty flavour burst of your olives.

How to Store Kalamata Olives

In an airtight container in your pantry. Once a jar of olives is open I keep them in the fridge.

Kalamata Olives Flavour Pairings

  • Anchovy & Olives
  • Fish & Olives
  • Capers & Olives
  • Tuna & Olives
  • Spinach (or other greens) & Olives
  • Feta & Olives

More Articles Similar to Olives Substitutes

Also see see the Simple Ingredients Substitutes Index.

Have fun in the kitchen!

With love,
Jules x

The Best Simple Kalamata Olives Substitutes (2024)

FAQs

What's a good substitute for kalamata olives? ›

The amazing substitutes for kalamata olives include Maddaleno olives, California black olives, capers, Nicoise olives or French black olives, Gaeta olives, and green olives.

What is the difference between Kalamata and Castelvetrano olives? ›

If the Kalamata olive is a red wine olive, then the Castelvetrano is a white wine olive, as its flavor complements the bright, crisp, lighter wine perfectly.

Can I use black olives instead of Kalamata? ›

That depends on your personal taste and what you plan to use them for. If you're looking for a mild, versatile olive that can be used in many dishes, black olives are a good choice. However, if you're looking for a more complex flavour and texture, Kalamata olives are definitely worth trying.

Can I substitute kalamata olives for nicoise olives? ›

If You Can't Find Niçoise Olives For Your Salad, Kalamata Are A Perfect Replacement.

What is equivalent to olives? ›

Capers, or pickled nasturtium pods, will add a similar salty-sour-bitter flavor note, but won't have the same mouth-feel, nor the umami note, that olives give.

What Flavour are Kalamata olives? ›

Characteristics. The Kalamata olives are plump, show a dark purple color and have an almond shape. Following processing, the polyphenol level remains high, which translate in a light bitter taste.

What are the healthiest olives to eat? ›

Kalamata olives may reduce your risks of heart disease. This is due to the presence of hydroxytyrosol in olives. Hydroxytyrosol is an antioxidant that has been shown to decrease LDL (bad) cholesterol and increase HDL (good) cholesterol levels.

How many olives should I eat a day? ›

We usually serve them as a snack for a drink or on top of salads, but olives shouldn't be eaten just for the taste. Did you know that experts recommend eating a small handful of olives a day? Eating just 7 olives each day is really good for you!

What are the best olives to snack on? ›

Kalamata. Often used in Greek salads, Kalamata olives have an intense, slightly salty yet fruity taste. They are a good all-round olive, popular for snacking and also good atop pizza.

Why are Kalamata olives so expensive? ›

Why Are Kalamata Olives So Expensive? The two different methods utilised in making bitter Kalamata olives, cured olives, helps to explain why they are generally more expensive than the average black olives and green olives from Greece.

Do Italians use Kalamata olives? ›

Although the Kalamata olives are Greek, they are an important part of the Italian culinary tradition. Even some Sicilian olive oils include a blend of Kalamata olive oil. Like many olives, these are too bitter to eat right at harvest. They have to be soaked in a brine or vinegar for about five months.

What is another name for Kalamata olives? ›

Like many European food specialties, they benefit from a D.O.P. given by the European Union. Only olives from the Kalamata cultivar, grown in a tight region around the town of Kalamata can be called “Kalamata”. Non-DOP versions exist – you will find them commercialized under names such as Kalamon or Calamat.

What can I substitute for Kalamata olives? ›

Simple Kalamata Olives Substitutes
  • Feta. This is taking things in a completely different direction but crumbled feta can provide a salty tang and burst of flavour to replace your olives. ...
  • Capers. ...
  • Gerkins or Cornichons. ...
  • Caper Berries. ...
  • Roast Almonds or Pinenuts. ...
  • Fresh Herbs. ...
  • Preserved Lemons. ...
  • Sea Salt Flakes.

Can I substitute Kalamata olives for capers? ›

Black or Kalamata olives can also bring a pop of brine, but with less caper-like bitterness. Due to the difference in size, substitute one olive for every two capers.

Why are Castelvetrano olives so good? ›

As mentioned before, its unique curing process paves the way for a remarkable flavor profile. Unlike other table olives, which often offer tart and pungent flavors, the Castelvetrano olive is characterized by a natural buttery and creamy flavor, complemented by a mild brininess.

What is the difference between olives and Kalamata olives? ›

Some people describe kalamata olives as “meaty” because they have a chewier texture than black olives, which are slightly soft. Kalamata olives also have a strong, almost fruity taste because they're tree-ripened. Black olives taste mild and less fruity since they're picked before they're ripe.

What is special about Kalamata olives? ›

Kalamata olives also contain iron, calcium and copper minerals that help with heart health, bone strength and reduced risk of anaemia. Kalamata olives are a good source of vitamins A and E that help maintain healthy eyesight and heart health respectively.

What olives are best for Greek food? ›

And what about table olives?
  • Kalamata. The most famous. ...
  • Conservolia. Representing 80% of all Greek table olives, it is the most important commercially and grown pretty much everywhere. ...
  • Megaritiki. Grows mainly in Attica (central-eastern Greece, in and around Athens). ...
  • Throumba (aka Throumbolia). ...
  • Halkidikis.

Why do Kalamata olives taste like wine? ›

Kalamata olives, for example, are cured in a red wine vinegar brine which helps give them their delicious, almost wine-like flavor. Some producers begin curing in a water bath, and then later shift their olives into a seasoned brine.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 6235

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Birthday: 2000-07-07

Address: 5050 Breitenberg Knoll, New Robert, MI 45409

Phone: +2556892639372

Job: Investor Mining Engineer

Hobby: Sketching, Cosplaying, Glassblowing, Genealogy, Crocheting, Archery, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is The Hon. Margery Christiansen, I am a bright, adorable, precious, inexpensive, gorgeous, comfortable, happy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.