Important: A Scone Is Not a Biscuit (2024)

I used to live down the street from a very charming all-day eatery. There was coffee and pastries in the morning, a manageable sandwich selection at lunch, and a navigable dinner menu. Theoretically it was the perfect spot to cozy up with a scone and a pot of tea on a "sick" day. But no, this was not a scone I would partake in. In fact, I was so offended by this scone that it still annoys me to this day.

What I gather these very kind folks did (and they really are so kind, so I feel extra bad complaining) was simply fold lemon zest and dried fruit into a buttermilk biscuit dough. A great way to streamline your prep list, sure, but it was also an excellent move to get on my last nerve. I've been accused of getting upset about the wrong/small things and not enough at the big stuff.

Point being, a biscuit is not a scone. Sure, they're made up of almost the same stuff—flour, leavener, fat, dairy—but they are two altogether different things and you better not try to trick me into thinking one is the other. Let me be clear that this is in no way a hate letter to biscuits. I love biscuits. I may marry one someday. But they are different then a scone and cannot, should not, be dressed up to look like one.

Biscuits should be light—airy even—with well-defined flaky layers. Tender, yes, but sturdy enough to support or be dragged through gravy, a runny egg yolk, or a generous serving of maple syrup. A scone should not flake like a biscuit. It can have layers of course, but they should err on the side of crumbly. A scone is slightly dryer than a biscuit and yet, when done well, not dry at all. Scones are intended to be consumed with a hot beverage of your choice after all. And clotted cream, or butter, or jam. Or, hell, all three.

A scone's finer crumb welcomes an addition, be it herbs, chocolate, or a simple handful of currants. Ever try to add raisins to a biscuit? Of course you haven't because you're not a crazy person. Would you want to eat that poor burned raisin hanging off a biscuit cliff for dear life? I didn't think so.

Look, I know my argument is slightly under-baked but this is one of the few food areas about which I have very definitive feelings. Can you tell?

So when Test Kitchen contributor Jess Damuck set out to develop a perfect scone recipe, I was watching. Very. Closely. Believe you me, we've had enough biscuits around here to know the difference. After eating about 48 scones each over the course of a few days, we knew she had nailed it. What we offer you here is a blank scone canvas. Tender, just crumbly enough, ready, able, and yielding to a number of delicious additions. I'm partial to the original myself but I'll bet you go for cinnamon-chocolate.

Call it a biscuit. Call it a scone. Just don't call it late for dinner (ha! sorry). No, really, just call it what it is.

Get the recipe: BA's Best Cream Scones

Important: A Scone Is Not a Biscuit (2024)

FAQs

Important: A Scone Is Not a Biscuit? ›

A scone should not flake like a biscuit.

What makes a scone different from a biscuit? ›

"Scones are typically made using a quick bread method with a higher ratio of liquid to flour, and sometimes no butter at all," says Snyder. In contrast, biscuits have a high ratio of butter, and the lamination process needed to achieve flaky layers is a key differentiator to scones.

Do Americans call a scone a biscuit? ›

Why Are Scones Called Biscuits in America? The reason scones are called biscuits in America is likely because the recipe to make Southern biscuits is similar to those used to make hardtack. Hardtack is a dense cracker or biscuit made of similar ingredients, but no dairy.

What is the point of a scone? ›

The purpose of a British scone is to be a lofty, feathery vehicle for jam and clotted cream and, above all, an accompaniment to tea.

What do British people call biscuits? ›

In Britain, what Americans refer to as “biscuits” are known as “scones.” British biscuits are actually what Americans call “cookies.” The term “biscuits” in the United Kingdom typically refers to sweet, crumbly, and sometimes buttery bakes treats, distinct from the soft, bread-like biscuits found in the United States.

What is the difference between a British scone and a US scone? ›

American scones use much more butter than British scones, and they usually have quite a bit more sugar. The extra butter is what makes them so much denser. This is not really a good or bad thing, as British scones pile on plenty of sugar (in the form of preserves/jam) and butter or clotted cream as toppings.

Are scones meant for breakfast? ›

In its most basic form, a scone is a baked quick bread that is usually eaten for breakfast or tea. Since its earliest known origin, the scone has taken on many forms, all the way to what we know today in sophisticated sweet and savory gourmet versions.

What do British call gravy? ›

Onion Gravy or Traditional British Gravy is what British people call gravy. Americans call it Brown Gravy, White Gravy (sawmill gravy or Breakfast Gravy), which is topped on biscuits. Brits don't put gravy on biscuits.

What do Brits call scones? ›

A Biscuit (U.S.) Is a Scone (U.K.)

A British biscuit is not remotely similar to the fluffy and filling American biscuits made famous in Southern American cuisine. The closest British equivalent to those buttery miracles is a scone, which ain't too bad either.

Why do people say scone differently? ›

It is more a matter of where you grew up. By and large, the pronunciation that rhymes with gone is more common, however.” “Our language continually reshapes itself,” she says. “New words appear.

What is the etiquette for eating a scone? ›

The Basics of Eating a Scone Properly

Break apart a small bite-sized portion of scone with your hands or if using a knife, cut the scone horizontally. Use a knife to slather on cream and jam onto the broken-off piece of scone. The bite-sized piece of scone should be eaten in 1-2 bites.

Why do you put eggs in scones? ›

You might need a teaspoon or two more cream as its consistency is thicker than milk. Large Egg - The egg helps bind the ingredients together and increases the richness and flavour. Unsalted butter - Has to be cold to create flaky layers within the scone.

What does scone mean in slang? ›

noun. skɒnskəʊn a light plain doughy cake made from flour with very little fat, cooked in an oven or (esp originally) on a griddle, usually split open and buttered. skɒn a slang word for head.

Are scones Irish or Scottish? ›

Scones are traditionally Irish, Scottish, and English foods. However, nobody knows which of these countries invented the baked food. As far as history can trace back, Scones probably originate from Scotland. Yes, the first print reference dates back to 1513 and is from a Scottish poet.

What is American gravy? ›

Most of what we call gravy in America is a bulked up pan sauce. At its best, gravy is made with the dripping from roasted meats, like beef or chicken/turkey or pork. Flour is added to the dripping and cooked like a roux, then milk or broth is added to make the sauce.

Are scones supposed to be hard or soft? ›

Scones are soft and tender, not chewy like a good loaf of sourdough.

Is a Southern biscuit a scone? ›

So there you have it: Southern biscuits have more butter and acidity (from the buttermilk), making them extra fluffy and flaky. While scones rely on richer, denser, ingredients like heavy cream and eggs to get a sturdy, yet crumbly, pastry. No matter which one you choose for breakfast, you can't go wrong.

What is the difference between a British biscuit and an American biscuit? ›

A British biscuit is what Americans know as a cookie or a cracker. In the United Kingdom, the word biscuit refers to any hard, thin, bread-like product. A distinguishing factor between an American cookie and a British biscuit is that a British biscuit must always have a “snap” because it is crispy.

Why do scones spread instead of rising? ›

The most likely reason I can think of is that you omitted the leavening, or what you used was flat. Another reason might be that your dough was too warm when you baked it, so it spread more while baking. Of course, scones are not yeast products, so they shouldn't rise as much as bread would.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Jamar Nader

Last Updated:

Views: 6499

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (75 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jamar Nader

Birthday: 1995-02-28

Address: Apt. 536 6162 Reichel Greens, Port Zackaryside, CT 22682-9804

Phone: +9958384818317

Job: IT Representative

Hobby: Scrapbooking, Hiking, Hunting, Kite flying, Blacksmithing, Video gaming, Foraging

Introduction: My name is Jamar Nader, I am a fine, shiny, colorful, bright, nice, perfect, curious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.